Best Cookies in New York City
New York City is known for many foods. The first NYC foods that come to mind are usually pizza, hot dogs, cheesecake, and bagels, but did you know New York City also has some of the best cookies in the world? These are cookies people are willing to travel from far and wide for. New York City has a cookie for every dietary restriction, preference, and taste. What is the best cookie in NYC? Is the best cookie in New York City thin and crispy? Thick and gooey? Has it been tasted by Oprah? Perhaps the best cookie in NYC comes from one of the Welcome to Times Square employees! Let’s see what cookies New York City has to offer, and then you can decide which is the best!
Thick and Gooey NYC Cookies
The best cookie in New York City comes down to personal preference. For some, the best cookie must be thick and gooey. You know, the kind of cookies that has that fresh out of the oven, maybe the inside even has a hint of melty raw cookie dough? If this is your favorite type of cookie, then there are two options you must try in New York City. The first is Levain. Levain consistently tops every list of best cookies in New York City. Levain was founded in 1995, and serves up giant 6-ounce cookies! Their signature cookie is a chocolate chip walnut, but fear not, there are nut-free options as well. The other thick and gooey cookie favorite is Funny Face Bakery. They’re really famous for making sugar cookies decorated to look like celebrities, but recommend you skip those and go right to their thick and gooey cookies! In a contest between Levain vs Funny Face, many people are shocked to learn they prefer Funny Face Bakery. We strongly believe you should try both! You only live once!
Thin and Crispy or Thin and Chewy Cookies
Some people prefer their cookies thin and crispy or thin and chewy. New York City has cookies for that as well. On the artisanal side, you’ll want to make a bee-line for Schmackary’s in Hell’s Kitchen. Schmackary’s is known as the “unofficial cookie of Broadway.” It was founded by an actor named Zachary Schmall. Schmackary’s has developed a loyal following from the theatre industry who love to swing in for a pre or post show snack. People are especially drawn to the fun flavors such as “Funfetti” at Schmackary’s. Since we are approaching Fall, look out for some yummy pumpkin and maple flavors at Schmackary’s. Another option for you would be Magnolia Bakery. Magnolia is best known for their cupcakes and banana puddy, but don’t sleep on their cookies. They definitely delight.
Fun Flavors and Famous NYC Cookies
Chip City is a cookie store in New York City that has been gaining a lot of traction. While smaller than Levain’s, Chip City definitely serves up warm and gooey cookies. Chip City is famous for their fun flavors. For example, they occasionally have a cornbread and Mike’s Hot Honey cookie, a baklava cookie, and a spiced hot chocolate churros cookie. All have a devastatingly chewy and delicious interior. Crumbl is another NYC cookie fan favorite. We also suggest you head to Unregular Bakery, owned by one of Welcome to Times Square’s very own. Unregular Bakery is a playful Italian bakery located just south of Union Square, and their cookies are divine. Finally, there is a vegan option for you! Confectionery serves up delightful cookies and everything in the bakery is vegan. We are especially big fans of their almond cookie!
As you walk about the city looking for cookies, take lots of photos! Put your photos on a Times Square billboard! For just $150 a day, you can appear on a giant Times Square billboard. Let Welcome to Times Square help you feel like a celebrity. It pairs perfectly with cookies!